We Roast the Turkey Overnight. Fast Turkey Is Dry Turkey.
You askedWhy do you roast the turkey overnight?
All four diners
The short answer
Because that's how long it takes to do it right. I tried it faster one time. The turkey noticed.
Mel · Last reviewed September 17, 2026
The turkey goes in when the dining room's dark and comes out about the time the first pot of coffee's on.
Fast turkey is dry turkey. There's no trick around it. No machine, no shortcut, no clever fella with a thermometer who figured out something the rest of us missed.
My mother did it this way, in a smaller oven, for less money and more people. She wasn't showing off. That's just the length of time a turkey takes.
If you want it done right, do it overnight.
Nobody sees that part, and that's fine. You're supposed to taste it, not watch it.
– Mel
While we have you
How long does Mel’s roast its turkey?
Overnight. It goes in when the dining room is dark and comes out about the time the first pot of coffee is on.
Why not cook the turkey faster?
Fast turkey is dry turkey. There is no shortcut around the time it takes.
Is the turkey made in house?
Yes, roasted in the building overnight.
More on menu, or read every answer below.
All of Mel’s answersWhile you’re here
Mel wasn’t finished
Menu · September 18, 2026
A Full Slab, Fries and Slaw. Fort Myers Has a Trophy for It.
Baby back ribs, a full slab, with natural-cut Idaho fries and Mel’s coleslaw. All four diners, takeout and catering included.
- ribs
- dinner
- awards
Menu · September 12, 2026
The Pie Is Made Here, Every Morning. Ask Whoever Beat the Sun In.
Every pie in that case got rolled out in this building before you were awake. The day we buy one, I'll put a sign on it.
- pie
- desserts
- from scratch
Locations · September 17, 2026
Four Mel’s Diners, One Coast. Here’s Which One Is Yours.
Addresses, hours and what each diner is best at, for all four Mel’s Diners in Southwest Florida.
- locations
- addresses
- bonita springs

