The Pie Is Made Here, Every Morning. Ask Whoever Beat the Sun In.
You askedIs the pie really made here, or do you just say that?
All four diners
The short answer
Every pie in that case got rolled out in this building before you were awake. The day we buy one, I'll put a sign on it.
Mel · Last reviewed September 17, 2026
That case by the register isn't decoration. It's inventory, and it moves.
Somebody's here before the sun with flour on their apron. Apple, key lime, chocolate cream, coconut cream, whatever the season is doing. Same as 1987, same as this morning.
People ask why we don't just buy them in. A bought pie costs us less and takes ten seconds to put in the case. It's also a lie in a glass box, and I've got grandchildren who can read.
A pie you didn't make is still a pie. It's just somebody else's.
My bakers do all of it. I carry the flour and stay out of the way.
So, made here. Ask for it warm. And if the coconut cream is gone by two o'clock, that ain't bad planning. That's a compliment.
– Mel
While we have you
Does Mel’s Diner make its own pie?
Yes. Every pie in the case is rolled out in the building each morning.
What pie flavours does Mel’s have?
Apple, key lime, chocolate cream, coconut cream, and whatever the season is doing.
Can I get pie warm?
Yes. Ask for it warm.
What time does the pie run out?
Some flavours go by early afternoon. The coconut cream is often gone by two.
More on menu, or read every answer below.
All of Mel’s answersWhile you’re here
Mel wasn’t finished
Menu · September 4, 2026
We Roast the Turkey Overnight. Fast Turkey Is Dry Turkey.
Because that's how long it takes to do it right. I tried it faster one time. The turkey noticed.
- turkey
- from scratch
- dinner
Menu · July 24, 2026
Real Ice Cream in Every Milkshake. You Get the Tin as Well.
Real ice cream, real tin, and you get whatever didn't fit in the glass. A fake milkshake is a lie, and I don't lie to children.
- milkshakes
- desserts
- kids
Menu · September 18, 2026
A Full Slab, Fries and Slaw. Fort Myers Has a Trophy for It.
Baby back ribs, a full slab, with natural-cut Idaho fries and Mel’s coleslaw. All four diners, takeout and catering included.
- ribs
- dinner
- awards

