
Real Ice Cream in Every Milkshake. You Get the Tin as Well.
You askedIs the milkshake really made with ice cream?
All four diners
The short answer
Real ice cream, real tin, and you get whatever didn't fit in the glass. A fake milkshake is a lie, and I don't lie to children.
Mel · Last reviewed September 17, 2026
Spun to order. Real ice cream, real milk, nothing out of a pump on the wall.
You get the glass, and you get the tin with the rest of it. The tin isn't a gimmick. It's the part that wouldn't fit, and it belongs to you.
Plenty of places use a mix. Costs less, pours faster, tastes like a photograph of a milkshake. A kid can tell. A kid can always tell.
Real ice cream. Real coffee. Real fair price. We're funny about the word 'real.'
– Mel
While we have you
Are Mel’s milkshakes made with real ice cream?
Yes. Real ice cream and real milk, spun to order, nothing out of a pump.
Do you get the tin with a milkshake?
Yes. The glass comes with the tin holding the rest of it.
Are milkshakes on the kids menu?
Yes, and it is the same real one.
More on menu, or read every answer below.
All of Mel’s answersWhile you’re here
Mel wasn’t finished
Menu · September 12, 2026
The Pie Is Made Here, Every Morning. Ask Whoever Beat the Sun In.
Every pie in that case got rolled out in this building before you were awake. The day we buy one, I'll put a sign on it.
- pie
- desserts
- from scratch
Menu · September 4, 2026
We Roast the Turkey Overnight. Fast Turkey Is Dry Turkey.
Because that's how long it takes to do it right. I tried it faster one time. The turkey noticed.
- turkey
- from scratch
- dinner
Value · September 17, 2026
Happy Hour Runs 3 to 6. Early Bird Beats It by an Hour.
Three o’clock is when the afternoon gets interesting. Happy hour to six, early bird to five, at all four diners.
- happy hour
- early bird
- specials

